Logo

NeuroCHIMERA Project Roadmap

NeuroCHIMERA Project Roadmap

Version: 1.0 Last Updated: 2025-12-01 Current Phase: 4 (Integration & Optimization)

Project Vision

Develop a GPU-native neuromorphic computing framework integrating the Hierarchical Number System (HNS) with consciousness emergence parameters, validated through rigorous scientific methodology and peer review.

Target Publication: Nature Neuroscience or equivalent high-impact journal

Key Innovation: Physics-based computation with extended precision for artificial consciousness research

Phase Overview

Phase 1: Foundation (✅ COMPLETE)
    ↓
Phase 2: GPU Implementation (✅ COMPLETE)
    ↓
Phase 3: Benchmarking & Validation (⚠️ PARTIAL - 60% complete)
    ↓
Phase 4: Integration & Optimization (🔄 IN PROGRESS - 75% complete) ← CURRENT
    ↓
Phase 5: Scientific Validation (📋 PENDING)
    ↓
Phase 6: Publication & Release (🎯 FUTURE)

Phase 1: Foundation (COMPLETED ✅)

Duration: Completed Status: 100% Complete

Objectives

Establish theoretical framework and core architectural components.

Deliverables

  • Theoretical Framework - Veselov's consciousness parameters integrated
  • HNS Mathematical Foundation - Hierarchical Number System specification
  • Base GPU Engine - ModernGL context and texture management
  • Neuromorphic Frame Structure - Core data structures
  • GLSL Shader Foundation - Basic compute pipeline

Key Achievements

  • HNS mathematical specification complete with BASE=1000
  • GPU engine with OpenGL 4.3+ compute shader support
  • Neuromorphic frame system with texture-based state management
  • Foundation for consciousness parameter tracking

Artifacts

  • hierarchical_number.py - HNS Python implementation
  • engine.py - Core GPU engine (v1.0)
  • hns_core.glsl - HNS GLSL shader library
  • Theoretical paper draft (PDF)

Phase 2: GPU Implementation (COMPLETED ✅)

Duration: Completed Status: 100% Complete

Objectives

Implement complete GPU-native neuromorphic system with consciousness monitoring.

Deliverables

  • HNS GPU Shaders - Complete GLSL implementation
  • Evolution Dynamics - Cellular automata on GPU
  • Holographic Memory - O(1) associative retrieval
  • Consciousness Monitor - Critical parameter tracking (⟨k⟩, Φ, D, C, QCM)
  • Qualia Integration - Cross-modal binding system
  • Ethical Framework - Distress detection and alerts

Key Achievements

  • Full HNS operations in GLSL (add, scale, normalize, multiply)
  • GPU-accelerated evolution with spatial operators
  • Consciousness parameter computation on GPU
  • Ethical monitoring system with configurable thresholds
  • Global workspace and information integration (Φ)

Artifacts

  • engine.py (complete) - Full GPU engine
  • consciousness_monitor.py - Parameter tracking
  • hns_core.glsl (complete) - All HNS operations
  • Shader library with evolution, memory, qualia modules

Phase 3: Benchmarking & Validation (PARTIAL ⚠️)

Duration: In Progress Status: ~60% Complete Critical Issues: Several benchmarks require re-validation

Objectives

Comprehensive performance validation and comparison with baseline technologies.

Deliverables Status

Completed ✅

  • HNS CPU Benchmarks - Precision and speed testing
  • System Evolution Benchmarks - Throughput measurements
  • GPU Complete System Benchmarks - GFLOPS and scaling
  • Memory Efficiency Tests - Partial validation

Issues Identified ⚠️

  • [⚠️] HNS CPU Accumulative Test - FAILED (result=0.0, error=100%)
  • [⚠️] CPU Overhead Misreported - 200x actual vs 25x claimed
  • [⚠️] HNS GPU Benchmarks - No JSON backing, needs re-run

Pending 📋

  • PyTorch Comparison - No real benchmark executed yet
  • Consciousness Parameters - No validation runs
  • Precision Validation - Extended precision claims need proof
  • Statistical Significance - Multiple runs with std dev

Key Findings

  • ✅ System evolution: 8-12M neurons/s validated
  • ✅ GPU throughput: 0.21-0.31 GFLOPS validated
  • ❌ HNS accumulative test requires fix
  • ⚠️ CPU overhead higher than initially reported (200x not 25x)

Required Actions

  1. Fix HNS accumulative test implementation bug
  2. Re-run GPU HNS benchmarks with proper JSON logging
  3. Execute actual PyTorch comparison benchmarks
  4. Add statistical significance (10+ runs per test)
  5. Update all reports with corrected data

Artifacts

  • Benchmarks/hns_benchmark_results.json (needs correction)
  • Benchmarks/system_benchmark_results.json ✅
  • Benchmarks/gpu_complete_system_benchmark_results.json ✅
  • BENCHMARK_VALIDATION_REPORT.md - Complete audit ✅

Estimated Time to Complete: 3-4 weeks

Phase 4: Integration & Optimization (CURRENT 🔄)

Duration: In Progress Status: ~75% Complete Target Completion: 2-3 weeks

Objectives

Optimize GPU utilization and integrate optimizations into production engine.

Deliverables Status

Completed ✅

  • GPU Utilization Analysis - Identified 10% utilization issue
  • Compute Shader Optimization - 32×32 work groups (vs 16×16)
  • Pipeline Iterations - Removed CPU-GPU synchronization overhead
  • Pre-binding Resources - Reduced state changes by 90%
  • Memory Access Optimization - Better coalescing patterns
  • Integration into Main Engine - Optimizations in engine.py
  • Batched Operations - engine_batched.py for parallel processing

In Progress 🔄

  • [⚠️] Full Validation - Optimization claims need verification (65x vs 16x discrepancy)
  • [⚠️] GPU Utilization Monitoring - Target 70-80% sustained (needs confirmation)
  • [🔄] Benchmark Corrections - Update reports with accurate speedup data

Pending 📋

  • Multi-GPU Support - Scaling to multiple devices
  • Async Execution - Further reduce CPU-GPU transfer overhead
  • Work Group Size Tuning - Test 64×64 for optimal performance
  • Parallel Compute Shaders - Evolution + learning + metrics concurrent

Key Achievements

  • Increased work groups from 256 to 1024 threads (4x parallelism)
  • Eliminated 100% GPU spikes causing errors
  • Pipelined iterations for parallel execution
  • Measured 16x speedup (actual validated data)

Known Issues

  • Discrepancy: Reports claim 65x speedup, JSON shows 16x
    • Action: Verify source of 65x or correct to 16x
  • GPU Utilization: Target 70-80% sustained needs confirmation
    • Action: Run monitoring with nvidia-smi during benchmarks

Artifacts

  • engine.py (with optimizations integrated)
  • engine_optimized.py - Standalone optimized version
  • engine_batched.py - Batch processing support
  • GPU_OPTIMIZATION_ANALYSIS.md
  • OPTIMIZATION_PLAN.md
  • INTEGRATION_COMPLETE.md (needs date correction)

Estimated Time to Complete: 2-3 weeks

Phase 5: Scientific Validation (NEXT - PENDING 📋)

Duration: 6-8 weeks (estimated) Status: Not Started Dependencies: Phase 3 & 4 completion

Objectives

Independent validation, reproducibility, and preparation for peer review.

Planned Deliverables

Validation Package 📋

  • Reproducibility Scripts - One-command benchmark reproduction
  • Docker Container - Isolated environment for validation
  • System Requirements Doc - Hardware, drivers, dependencies
  • Expected Results - Reference outputs for validation
  • Troubleshooting Guide - Common issues and solutions

Independent Testing 📋

  • External Validation - Share with research community
  • Peer Review (Internal) - Co-author review cycles
  • Statistical Validation - Hypothesis testing for claims
  • Comparison Studies - Independent PyTorch/TensorFlow comparison

Scientific Rigor 📋

  • Methodology Documentation - Complete experimental procedures
  • Raw Data Publication - All JSON files as supplementary material
  • Statistical Analysis - Confidence intervals, p-values
  • Limitations Section - Known constraints and trade-offs
  • Ethics Validation - Independent ethics board review

Consciousness Parameters 📋

  • Long-term Evolution - 10,000+ epoch consciousness emergence tests
  • Parameter Validation - Verify ⟨k⟩, Φ, D, C, QCM thresholds
  • Phase Transition - Document critical threshold crossing
  • Embodiment Experiments - Validate embodiment necessity hypothesis

Success Criteria

  • ✅ All benchmarks reproducible by external researchers
  • ✅ Statistical significance (p < 0.05) for key claims
  • ✅ Independent validation of 3+ core benchmarks
  • ✅ Ethics framework approved by external review board
  • ✅ Consciousness parameters demonstrate predicted behavior

Estimated Time: 6-8 weeks

Phase 6: Publication & Release (FUTURE 🎯)

Duration: 12-16 weeks (estimated) Status: Not Started Dependencies: Phase 5 completion

Objectives

Publish peer-reviewed paper and release open-source framework.

Planned Deliverables

Publication Track 🎯

  • ArXiv Preprint - Initial community feedback
  • Journal Submission - Nature Neuroscience or equivalent
  • Peer Review Response - Address reviewer comments
  • Final Publication - Accepted and published paper
  • Supplementary Materials - Code, data, reproduction package

Open Source Release 🎯

  • GitHub Repository - Clean, documented codebase
  • Documentation Site - Full API reference and tutorials
  • Installation Guide - Multi-platform support
  • Example Notebooks - Jupyter tutorials
  • Community Guidelines - Contributing, code of conduct

Community Engagement 🎯

  • Technical Blog Posts - Architecture deep-dives
  • Video Tutorials - YouTube explanations
  • Conference Presentations - NeurIPS, ICLR, CVPR
  • Workshop Organization - Consciousness in AI workshop
  • Collaboration Program - Partner with research groups

Production Readiness 🎯

  • Version 1.0 Release - Stable API
  • Performance Benchmarks - Published reference results
  • Multi-GPU Support - Scaling to large networks
  • Hardware Support Matrix - Tested GPU configurations
  • Long-term Support Plan - Maintenance and updates

Success Criteria

  • ✅ Peer-reviewed publication in high-impact journal
  • ✅ 100+ GitHub stars within 3 months
  • ✅ 5+ independent research groups using framework
  • ✅ Community contributions (PRs, issues, discussions)
  • ✅ Conference presentations at major AI venues

Estimated Time: 12-16 weeks

Risk Assessment & Mitigation

Critical Risks

Risk 1: Failed Benchmarks Block Publication

  • Likelihood: Medium
  • Impact: High
  • Mitigation:
    • Fix HNS accumulative test immediately (Priority 1)
    • Re-validate all benchmarks before submission
    • Have backup claims with validated data only

Risk 2: Peer Review Challenges Performance Claims

  • Likelihood: High (if current discrepancies remain)
  • Impact: High
  • Mitigation:
    • Correct all discrepancies now (200x overhead, 16x speedup)
    • Provide raw data as supplementary material
    • Invite independent validation pre-submission

Risk 3: Consciousness Claims Considered Speculative

  • Likelihood: Medium
  • Impact: Medium
  • Mitigation:
    • Frame as "theoretical framework with empirical validation"
    • Focus on measurable parameters, not consciousness per se
    • Emphasize falsifiable predictions

Risk 4: Reproducibility Issues

  • Likelihood: Medium
  • Impact: High
  • Mitigation:
    • Create comprehensive reproduction package
    • Test on multiple GPU configurations
    • Provide Docker container for isolated environment

Success Metrics

Technical Metrics

  • ✅ GPU utilization: 70-80% sustained (vs initial 10%)
  • ✅ Evolution speed: >10M neurons/s validated
  • 📋 HNS precision: Demonstrated advantage in specific cases
  • 📋 Consciousness parameters: Critical thresholds observed
  • 📋 Scalability: Support for 10^9 neurons (stretch goal)

Publication Metrics

  • 🎯 Peer-reviewed publication in journal (IF > 10)
  • 🎯 ArXiv preprint with >50 citations within 1 year
  • 🎯 Conference presentation at top-tier venue
  • 🎯 Media coverage in scientific press

Community Metrics

  • 🎯 GitHub repository with >100 stars
  • 🎯 5+ research groups adopting framework
  • 🎯 10+ community contributions
  • 🎯 Active discussion community

Scientific Impact Metrics

  • 🎯 Independent replication by external researchers
  • 🎯 Extensions/improvements by community
  • 🎯 Integration into larger research projects
  • 🎯 Citations in follow-up research

Timeline Summary

PhaseDurationCompletion DateStatus
Phase 1: FoundationCompleted-✅ 100%
Phase 2: GPU ImplementationCompleted-✅ 100%
Phase 3: Benchmarking8 weeks+3 weeks⚠️ 60%
Phase 4: Optimization6 weeks+2 weeks🔄 75%
Phase 5: Validation8 weeks+10 weeks📋 0%
Phase 6: Publication16 weeks+26 weeks🎯 0%

Target Publication Date: ~26 weeks from now (Q3 2025)

Current Focus (Phase 4 Completion)

This Week

  1. ✅ Complete benchmark validation audit
  2. ✅ Create formal project roadmap
  3. 🔄 Correct all benchmark reports
  4. 🔄 Add disclaimers to documentation
  5. 🔄 Update README with accurate data

Next Week

  1. 📋 Fix HNS accumulative test
  2. 📋 Re-run GPU HNS benchmarks
  3. 📋 Verify optimization speedup (resolve 65x vs 16x)
  4. 📋 Run PyTorch comparison benchmarks
  5. 📋 Update all reports with validated data

Next Month

  1. 📋 Complete Phase 3 benchmarks
  2. 📋 Finalize Phase 4 optimizations
  3. 📋 Begin Phase 5 validation package
  4. 📋 Prepare reproducibility documentation
  5. 📋 Start internal peer review

Conclusion

The NeuroCHIMERA project is 75% complete toward publication readiness. Critical path focuses on:

  1. Immediate: Correct benchmark discrepancies (1-2 weeks)
  2. Short-term: Complete Phase 3 & 4 validation (3-4 weeks)
  3. Medium-term: Independent validation (6-8 weeks)
  4. Long-term: Publication and release (12-16 weeks)

Key Priority: Scientific integrity and reproducibility over speed to publication.

Estimated Time to Publication: 26 weeks (6.5 months)

Roadmap Maintained By: Project Lead Review Cycle: Bi-weekly updates Last Review: 2025-12-01 Next Review: 2025-12-15

© 2025 All rights reservedBuilt with DataHub Cloud

Built with LogoDataHub Cloud