Test Results Analysis

Data Consistency ✅

Status: All checks passed

• ✅ All services have final_route_source=false (correct - they have children)
• ✅ All categories have final_route_source=false (correct - they have children)
• ✅ All collections have final_route_source=true (correct - they are leaf nodes)
• ✅ All parent references are valid
• ✅ Total 24 nodes in Qdrant: 4 services, 10 categories, 10 collections

Test Results Summary

Overall: 15/25 tests passing (60% success rate)

✅ Passing Tests (15)

1. REST API Service - All 4 tests passing

   • Service Health API (developer/admin)
   • Third-Party Integration API (developer/admin)

2. MCP Protocol Service - All 4 tests passing

   • Model Configuration Context (developer/admin)
   • Workflow Automation Context (developer/admin)

3. Document Search Service - 3/7 tests passing

   • IT Policy Documents (admin) ✅
   • System Architecture Docs (developer/admin) ✅
   • Role validation (user denied access) ✅

4. SQL Database Service - 2/7 tests passing

   • Some queries working but matching wrong collections

❌ Failing Tests (10)

Issue 1: Semantic Matching Accuracy

• Problem: Queries matching wrong collections
  • "Show network device inventory" → Matched "Model Configuration Context" (should be "Server Inventory Database")
  • "Show me system architecture" → Matched "Model Configuration Context" (should be "System Architecture Documentation")
• Root Cause: Embedding similarity may not be strong enough, or context matching needs improvement

Issue 2: Role-Based Access Control

• Problem: Some roles not working as expected
  • "it-support" role not accessing "Troubleshooting Guides" (should have access)
  • "user" role not accessing "Troubleshooting Guides" (should have access)
• Root Cause: Need to verify allowed_roles in Qdrant payloads

Issue 3: Empty Error Responses

• Problem: Some queries returning empty error codes instead of proper error messages
  • "List all production servers" → Empty error
  • "List all hardware assets" → Empty error
  • "Show application performance metrics" → Empty error
• Root Cause: Possible issue in error handling or routing logic

Issue 4: Error Code Mismatch

• Problem: Expected NO_RESOURCES but got VALIDATION_FAILED
  • "Find information about cooking recipes" → Should return NO_RESOURCES for no matching service
  • "Search for documentation" → Should return NO_RESOURCES for service-level query

Recommendations

1. Fix Role-Based Access Control

• Verify allowed_roles are correctly stored in Qdrant payloads
• Check role validation logic in routing orchestrator
• Ensure "it-support" and "user" roles are properly handled

2. Improve Semantic Matching

• Review embedding generation for collections
• Enhance context matching logic
• Consider adding query-to-collection mapping validation

3. Fix Error Handling

• Ensure proper error codes are returned
• Add error messages for debugging
• Handle edge cases (no matches, service-level queries)

4. Data Verification

• Verify all allowed_roles arrays are correctly stored
• Check that role validation is working at collection level
• Ensure parent-child relationships are correctly indexed

Next Steps

1. Investigate Role Access Issues

   • Check Qdrant payloads for allowed_roles field
   • Verify role validation logic
   • Test with different role combinations

2. Improve Semantic Matching

   • Review embedding weights
   • Test with more specific queries
   • Consider adding query pattern matching

3. Fix Error Handling

   • Add proper error codes
   • Improve error messages
   • Handle edge cases

4. Re-run Test Suite

   • After fixes, re-run comprehensive test suite
   • Target: 90%+ success rate